The great 'atria' schemes of the 1970s and 1980s, led by Roche and Dinkeloo's Ford Foundation in New York (1967), demonstrated that although extensive indoor planting in well daylit interior spaces is possible, it is almost always technically challenging and often expensive to maintain. In contemporary developments, large areas of open, top-lit 'public' space are rare, so indoor planting schemes can usually only be sustained by artificial means. With justifiable pressure from all sides to reduce the carbon footprint of buildings, it seems counterintuitive to be using so much light energy to keep plants alive indoors. Add in the cost of heat management, ventilation, water, and nutrients and the environmental (and capital) costs become even bigger – and make even less sense.